Help Sorting Data

I have a spreadsheet that I'm using to keep track of stats for players in a league. This is the link:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/193GxNzaX4-bGrNB8eT4vhqAOKhUrChRDgq-HYVU_Txk/edit#gid=1738544316

What I'm trying to have it do, is search the "Stats Gathering" sheet for the value in the C Column. When it finds that value, I want it to return the value of the A Column on the "Stats Gathering" sheet, i.e. their name.

I looked up a guide on youtube and it told me to importrange, which i did. This is the formula I've been using:

=VLOOKUP(C3, importrange("193GxNzaX4-bGrNB8eT4vhqAOKhUrChRDgq-HYVU_Txk", "Stats Gathering!A3:W43"), 1, FALSE)

Any idea what I'm doing wrong?

EDIT: Forgot to mention. The error its giving is it says it can't find the value '10.5' in VLOOKUP evaluation. So essentially, anything in the C3 column, it says it can't find it in the importrange, even though it's in there.